Stop choosing vendors based on price. Start choosing partners based on business value.
A strategic framework for evaluating agencies, venues, AV, registration, production, DMCs, transportation, catering, technology partners, and freelancers.
Interactive scorecard — fill it out in your browser. Your progress is saved automatically. Use Download PDF at the top to save a copy, or Reset to start over.
By Sara Straw
One of the biggest mistakes event teams make is treating vendors like suppliers.
This workbook helps you evaluate vendors consistently, objectively, and strategically — whether you're comparing agencies, venues, tech platforms, or freelancers.
Every partner you sign is a business decision. Treat it like one.
Current Provider?
Score each criterion 1–5. Every criterion is weighted equally (×10).
| Criteria | Weight | Score (1–5) |
|---|---|---|
| Industry Experience | 10 | |
| Event Experience | 10 | |
| Technical Expertise | 10 | |
| Team Quality | 10 | |
| Innovation | 10 | |
| Scalability | 10 | |
| Global Support | 10 | |
| Client References | 10 | |
| Financial Stability | 10 | |
| Cultural Fit | 10 |
Capability Score
0 / 50
Rate each 1–5.
| Criteria | Score (1–5) |
|---|---|
| Communication | |
| Responsiveness | |
| Problem Solving | |
| Strategic Thinking | |
| Creativity | |
| Attention to Detail | |
| Project Management | |
| Flexibility | |
| Executive Presence | |
| Professionalism |
Service Score
0 / 50
Rate each 1–5.
| Criteria | Score (1–5) |
|---|---|
| Pricing | |
| Payment Terms | |
| Contract Flexibility | |
| Transparency | |
| Change Orders | |
| Renewal Terms | |
| Cancellation Terms | |
| Insurance | |
| Legal Risk | |
| Overall Value |
Commercial Score
0 / 50
Answer honestly. Discomfort here is the point.
Would I trust this vendor with our flagship conference?
Could they support us globally?
Would I recommend them to another executive?
What happens if their project manager leaves?
Can they scale with our growth?
Live totals roll up from the sections above. Rate the subjective categories 1–5.
Capability
0 / 50
Service
0 / 50
Commercial
0 / 50
| Category | Score (1–5) |
|---|---|
| Risk | |
| Innovation | |
| Overall |
Recommendation
One of the biggest mistakes organizations make is evaluating vendors only during procurement.
Ask yourself:
Would I trust this partner during a crisis?
If the answer isn't an immediate yes...
Keep looking.
Bonus · AI Prompt Companion
Use these prompts with ChatGPT, Claude, or your preferred AI assistant to accelerate vendor evaluations while keeping your own expertise at the center of every decision.
You are a Senior Director of Corporate Events evaluating multiple vendors for a strategic event program. Compare the attached proposals and evaluate each vendor based on: relevant event experience, team expertise, creativity, scalability, risk, communication approach, pricing transparency, and overall strategic value. Present the findings in an executive comparison table with strengths, weaknesses, risks, and a final recommendation.
Review this vendor proposal and summarize it for executive leadership. Include: Executive Summary, Services Offered, Pricing Overview, Strengths, Potential Risks, Questions for Follow-up, and Overall Recommendation. Limit the summary to one page.
Generate 20 strategic interview questions for evaluating an event production agency supporting a flagship conference. Focus on: innovation, executive communication, crisis management, global scalability, budget management, customer experience, AI capabilities, and measurement and reporting.
Review this proposal like a procurement and legal team. Identify: missing deliverables, hidden costs, contract risks, timeline concerns, staffing assumptions, potential change orders, and questions that should be clarified before signing.
Based on the attached proposal and meeting notes, score the vendor from 1–5 across: Experience, Innovation, Pricing, Communication, Reliability, Strategic Thinking, Technology, and Executive Presence. Explain each score.
Draft a one-page recommendation to executive leadership explaining why Vendor A should be selected over Vendor B. Focus on business value, strategic alignment, risk, ROI, and long-term partnership potential.
Continue Building Your Toolkit
Designed to help event leaders make smarter decisions, build stronger strategies, and create measurable business impact.
